FP4 Plus in D-76 1+1: finding a baseline
Before experimenting with anything, I wanted one film and one developer I could trust. Eleven minutes, gentle agitation, and the negatives I now compare everything else against.

For my first months I changed something on every roll. A different film, a different developer, a different time I found on a forum. The result was a box of negatives that all looked different, and no way of knowing why. So in March I stopped and picked one combination to learn properly: FP4 Plus at box speed, D-76 diluted one to one.
There is nothing clever about it. FP4 is slow and forgiving, D-76 is the developer every data sheet is written against, and diluting it gives a little more sharpness and lets me throw the developer away after one use.
The routine I settled on
| Step | Time | What I do |
|---|---|---|
| Pre-wash | 1 min | Water at 20 °C, just to bring the tank to temperature |
| D-76 1+1 | 11 min | First 30 s continuous inversions, then 4 inversions every minute |
| Stop | 1 min | Plain water, three changes |
| Fix | 5 min | Rapid fixer 1+4, inversions every 30 s |
| Wash | 10 min | Fill and invert 5, 10 and 20 times, then running water |
| Wetting agent | 30 s | One drop too many is worse than none |
The data sheet time for 1+1 is eleven minutes at 20 °C. I tried 10 and 12 as well, on the same subject photographed three times on the same afternoon. Ten looked flat, twelve made the sky on a bright day print like a white sheet. Eleven it is.

Exposure first
What surprised me was how much more exposure mattered than development. When I rated FP4 at 125 and metered for the shadows, the negatives printed easily whatever I did in the tank. When I metered for the sky, no amount of extra development brought the shadows back. That lesson cost me four rolls and has saved me many more since.

Why bother with a baseline
Now, when something looks wrong, I have a reference. If a roll comes out thin, I can put it on the light box next to a strip of FP4 from March and see whether the film base is the same and only the image is weaker, which points at exposure, or whether the whole strip looks pale, which points at the developer.
I still shoot other films. But every time I start with a new developer, the first roll through it is FP4, and I photograph the same corner of the same courtyard. It is a dull picture. It is also the most useful one I own.

— Elin, 24 March 2024