Tri-X and HP5 side by side on a grey week
Two classic 400-speed films, the same flat light, the same developer. The differences are real but smaller than the internet says.

Ask ten people about Tri-X and HP5 and you get ten confident answers. Tri-X has more bite, HP5 is softer, Tri-X has the classic look, HP5 pushes better. I had shot both, but never on the same days in the same light, so I could not honestly say which differences were the film and which were the weather.
In July we had a week of solid grey sky, the kind of week that is useless for most things and perfect for this. I loaded the two films into two bodies with the same lens and shot the same scenes in pairs, both rated at 400.

Development
Both rolls went into D-76 1+1 together, in one two-reel tank, for the time that sits between the two data sheets: 10 minutes at 20 °C. Developing them together meant the same dilution, temperature and agitation, so the only variable left was the film.
| Film | Data sheet, D-76 1+1, 20 °C | What I used |
|---|---|---|
| Tri-X 400 | 9 min 45 s | 10 min |
| HP5 Plus | 13 min | 10 min |
On paper that means the HP5 was slightly underdeveloped, and on the light box it showed: a little thinner, a little lower in contrast. For a fair comparison I printed both at the contrast grade that gave each its best print.
What I saw

Once printed properly, the differences were small. Tri-X had a slightly brighter look in the midtones and its grain was a touch more defined, crisper at the edges. HP5 had a gentler roll-off into the highlights; on a white sky the transition from grey to paper white was smoother. In the shadows, the two were nearly identical.
If I put the prints in a shuffled pile, I could pick the Tri-X in seven pairs out of ten. That is better than guessing and worse than the forums would have you believe.
Which one I use
Mostly HP5, because it is easier to get here and a little cheaper. Tri-X when I know the light will be flat and I want the extra snap without changing development. And the honest conclusion from this week is that my exposure and printing decide much more about how a picture looks than which yellow or grey box the film came in.

— Elin, 20 July 2025