Quiet Darkroom

· Developing · Tri-X, HP5 Plus · 2 min read

Tri-X and HP5 side by side on a grey week

Two classic 400-speed films, the same flat light, the same developer. The differences are real but smaller than the internet says.

Apartment blocks seen through a window on a grey day.
Apartment blocks seen through a window on a grey day.

Ask ten people about Tri-X and HP5 and you get ten confident answers. Tri-X has more bite, HP5 is softer, Tri-X has the classic look, HP5 pushes better. I had shot both, but never on the same days in the same light, so I could not honestly say which differences were the film and which were the weather.

In July we had a week of solid grey sky, the kind of week that is useless for most things and perfect for this. I loaded the two films into two bodies with the same lens and shot the same scenes in pairs, both rated at 400.

Two rangefinder bodies side by side, one for each film.
Two rangefinder bodies side by side, one for each film.

Development

Both rolls went into D-76 1+1 together, in one two-reel tank, for the time that sits between the two data sheets: 10 minutes at 20 °C. Developing them together meant the same dilution, temperature and agitation, so the only variable left was the film.

FilmData sheet, D-76 1+1, 20 °CWhat I used
Tri-X 4009 min 45 s10 min
HP5 Plus13 min10 min

On paper that means the HP5 was slightly underdeveloped, and on the light box it showed: a little thinner, a little lower in contrast. For a fair comparison I printed both at the contrast grade that gave each its best print.

What I saw

A street beneath concrete viaducts.
A street beneath concrete viaducts.

Once printed properly, the differences were small. Tri-X had a slightly brighter look in the midtones and its grain was a touch more defined, crisper at the edges. HP5 had a gentler roll-off into the highlights; on a white sky the transition from grey to paper white was smoother. In the shadows, the two were nearly identical.

If I put the prints in a shuffled pile, I could pick the Tri-X in seven pairs out of ten. That is better than guessing and worse than the forums would have you believe.

Which one I use

Mostly HP5, because it is easier to get here and a little cheaper. Tri-X when I know the light will be flat and I want the extra snap without changing development. And the honest conclusion from this week is that my exposure and printing decide much more about how a picture looks than which yellow or grey box the film came in.

Bare trees beside elevated railway tracks.
Bare trees beside elevated railway tracks.

— Elin, 20 July 2025