Quiet Darkroom

· Cameras · HP5 Plus · 2 min read

Sunny 16, and a meter that lies by a stop

My old selenium meter reads one stop under in dim light. How I found out, how I compensate, and why I now trust a rule of thumb from a film box.

A selenium light meter: no battery, just a cell, a needle and a dial.
A selenium light meter: no battery, just a cell, a needle and a dial.

The handheld meter I bought with the folding camera is the old kind with a selenium cell. It needs no battery: light falling on the cell makes a tiny current, and that current moves the needle. The catch is that selenium cells get tired with age, and they get tired unevenly. Mine is accurate in bright light and optimistic in the shade.

How I found out

A roll shot under the trees in the park came back thin, while a roll from the beach the same week was perfect. Same film, same developer. I compared the meter against a phone app and against the meter in a newer camera, at ten different spots around the flat. In sunlight they all agreed. In a dim room, the old meter read one stop more light than was really there.

SceneOld meterNewer cameraDifference
Street in full sun1/250 at f/161/250 at f/160
Open shade1/250 at f/81/125 at f/81 stop
Living room, evening1/30 at f/2.81/15 at f/2.81 stop

Sunny 16

On bright days I now mostly ignore the meter. The old rule printed inside film boxes still works: in full sun, at f/16, the shutter speed is one over the film speed. For HP5 at 400 that is 1/500 at f/16, or 1/250 at f/22 if the camera does not go that fast. Light overcast, open up one stop. Heavy overcast, two. Open shade, three.

A steel truss bridge under a bright, broken sky.
A steel truss bridge under a bright, broken sky.

What surprised me is how quickly it becomes automatic. After a month I could look at a street and say "f/8 at 1/250" before I lifted the meter, and the meter would agree.

A stairway in open shade, three stops darker than the sunny side of the street.
A stairway in open shade, three stops darker than the sunny side of the street.

Compensating

In dim light I set the meter's dial to half the film speed: HP5 becomes 200 on the dial. That adds the missing stop. Black-and-white negative film is forgiving of overexposure, so being generous costs very little, while one stop under means empty shadows that nothing can rescue.

I could buy a newer meter. But this one fits in a coat pocket, needs no battery, and now that I know how it lies, it tells me the truth.

An old handheld exposure meter.
An old handheld exposure meter.

— Elin, 13 October 2024